Your List

[QueenBex]

I'd much rather add Lucy Lawless and Renee O'Connor to my list (presuming I was in some female incarnation; the thought of either of them with a dude is kinda weird).

Oh my yes, I had a huge crush on Lucy Lawless watching that show!

Hugh Jackman is some kind of god I swear, he does it all and with a charm all his own.

I've always had a thing for Stephen Fry, i'd happily have a sex change for him!

I had a crush on Julia Bradbury for a while but its kind of dwindled, i don't like the photo shoots, I prefer her in her walking gear deep in the lake district covered in mud, rain dripping off her nose. *sigh* ok maybe that crush is still there

Eddie Izzard... Well I wouldn't say no

Payton Manning, *fans self* oh my! A fine NFL player! I admire Roethlisberger but he's not for me.

I may come back to this...

[Ally]

Chris Cornell. Gorgeous man and incredible singer. The first time I saw him in concert was at a solo acoustic show. He did an acoustic cover of Michael Jackson's 'Billie Jean' that marks for me the first time I've ever felt even a little bit inclined to toss my panties onstage.
[...]
Dave Grohl. Just because!

Dave Grohl, though... a decade ago, I posited that it was a good thing that he was an impossibly good drummer, because he was the most unattractive man I'd ever seen. Holds true to this day.

I agree he's not the best looking fella going 'round, but he seems like a nice guy! That and he's an incredible musician! I wouldn't let him stop playing songs (and I know from watching the Nirvana Unplugged DVD that he can in fact play multiple instruments at once )
Gotta tell you ladies, I don't really get the whole Hugh Jackman thing! National pride tells me I should, but I just don't see it! If I have to pick a fellow Aussie I'd have to give it to Sam Worthington!

[BooChocoBoom]

Me and my geek girls, on one of our long ago wine nights (sigh, I miss them but sadly even geek girls have catty tiffs, it seems) listed our Ultimate Top Ten, our Guy Top Ten, our Girl Top Ten, our "Dirty" Top Ten, and our "Old" Top Ten. Very, very interesting things came out of this. LOL

My spousal "hall pass" list is as follows, though:

1. Brad Pitt - always and forever, have I loved this man...
2. Norman Reedus - my favorite Boondock bad boy and zombie hunter
3. Johnny Depp - my very close third - ever since 21 Jump Street, my friends
4. Milla Jovovich - I would let this woman kick my ass in any way she wanted as long as we had fun making up after
5. Christian Bale - my brooding, beautiful Newsie
6. David Bowie - it's not weird at all...have you SEEN the bulge in Labyrinth?!?
7. Gwyneth Paltrow - my dear waif, sigh
8. Joe Manganiello - He is hilarious and delicious
9. Sandra Bullock - the girl next door put a spell on me in Practical Magic and hasn't let go
10. Juliette Binoche - this is kind of a tie with Sophie Marceau, these gorgeous French women
Wild card - Jason Mewes - this guy has cracked me up for years and would be the most likely to actually take an offer

Yeah, we've thought about this quite a bit. LOL

[rockinwithrammstein]

Oh, I love this topic! I have an odd...odd list though, I think.

My list
Toby Turner from Annoying Orange (don't laugh)
Patrick Stewart <33333
I'm glad to see I'm not the only David Bowie fan
Liam Neeson and his sexy, sexy voice...
Hugh Laurie

Gimme some time, I'm sure there's more lol

[QueenBex]

Oh wow nice list Boo!! I'm certainly adding Johnny Depp and Sandra Bullock to my list! How could I not!!

[QueenBex]

Oh and add Helena Bonham Carter too!

Patrick Stewart <33333

I really don't see this. He's a great person but....

[rockinwithrammstein]

Patrick Stewart <33333

I really don't see this. He's a great person but....

I warned you my list was odd lol

[MeiTow]

Queen B-> Payton over Eli...really?! At least one of them is Superbowl bound this year. Tee hee. I have no idea why but I have a slight crush on our Luck but the neckbeard...*shiver*

I have an odd list too...mainly because I prefer pretty over rugged but here goes....

My first celebrity crush was Christian Slater so I keep him on the list even though he's a douche.
In the same doucheiness vein...Russell Crowe...my only rugged man crush, although he cleans up pretty.

Those two I'd get down and dirty with but wouldn't want a relationship.

Others:
Zachary Levi
Sam Huntington
Jared Padalecki
Benedict Cumberbatch
Ian Somerhalder
Zac Efron
Gary Oldman (my man of 1000 accents)
Eddie Izzard
Chris O'Dowd
Barry Fitzgerald
Michael Greyeyes (totally not enough delicious Native men in show business)

My "Go gay for" List:
Sandra Bullock (although I preferred her more pre-plastic surgery)
Sofia Vergara
Queen Latifah

[QueenBex]

Queen B-> Payton over Eli...really?! At least one of them is Superbowl bound this year. Tee hee. I have no idea why but I have a slight crush on our Luck but the neckbeard...*shiver*

Yep Payton! Don't know why but Eli doesn't do it for me...

Uhhh yeah the 'neckbeard' he's much better clean shaven. Theres a lot of odd hair styles and facial hair in the NFL.

From my Bears, Jay Cutler, Lance Briggs.

[TigerLily]

Karl Urban

I dunno. I try to see him as Bones, but then I remember him as Julius Caesar during his Xena: Warrior Princess days, and it makes me think I'd much rather add Lucy Lawless and Renee O'Connor to my list (presuming I was in some female incarnation; the thought of either of them with a dude is kinda weird).

Give me Bones or Judge Dredd and I can ignore all else.